As great as this had been, in the back of my mind I was nervous and anxious to be on the receiving end. Keith had clearly loved it so the odds were that I would too. I pulled my now spent organ out of him and immediately started preparing for my turn at getting fucked. What position to use was my most pressing decision as he fingered me slowly. When a second finger joined the first and I knew my time to make a choice was now.
Soon he asked, “I think you’re as ready as you’ll ever be, how would you like me to fuck you?” I wanted to be able to see his cock approaching me as well as see each other’s faces. There was one I’d seen that would work but I was afraid it could be too gay for Keith.
Finally I thought “if he doesn’t like it we can just try something else.” and I flopped down on my back then pulled my knees to my chest. “God! You should see how your hole looks this way! I can’t wait to get inside that! But I’ll go slow anyway.”
Keith’s cock was a bit thicker and much longer than mine and I worried I might not be able to take the whole thing. As he got in position before me I was mesmerized watching it coming directly at me glistening with a heavy coat of lube. I lost sight of it as his hand guided it down to where my own body blocked my view. A titillating wave swept through me when the succulent bulb of his organ touched my anxious private hole and began seeking entry.
The gentle pressure gradually got more and more insistent but I relaxed as much as I could and the head started sliding through the muscular grip of my anus. Keith’s face was now over mine and my legs were over his shoulders as he looked down into my eyes reading my facial cues. “You’re gonna love this! Ready?” I just nodded. He lowered his hips toward my pelvis and his slippery, engorged penis slipped with the most exquisite pleasure deep into the lusty passage of my rectum! I was getting FUCKED!
It nearly took my breath away! “My god! Your ass feels so good! How is it for you?” I appreciated the genuine concern in his voice. “Great! Just fuck me!” I nearly begged. And did he ever! His balls pummeled my anal region as I clasped my legs behind my knees, hugging them to my chest in hopes Keith could somehow go even deeper. It was cool seeing the reflection of me getting fucked in the bedroom mirror. It was as though I was one of the guys in the porn films and finally feeling what they did!
Keith’s endurance was great and we tried several positions, then he put me in the kneeling, edge of bed doggystyle one I had first fucked him in. I knew the view he’d be enjoying this way. It didn’t take long this way and his hands gripped my haunches hard, he let out and big grunt and I felt a powerful jet of his cum burst against my rectal walls! Pulse after pulse shot into me then finally subsided. Upon pulling out of me we both collapsed on the bed and knapped long and hard.
We do it often now, even daily. We doubt we’ll ever give up girls, but for some reason we don’t obsess over them like we used to. Now please excuse me, I need to go to the store, we’re almost out of lube!