He backed up and noticed that her outer labia, which parted perfectly to reveal her pink flower, was flushing the same shade of pink as her cheeks.
The effect made her pussy look amazing, and I attacked it with renewed vigor.
I closed my eyes, imagining it was Sabine’s pussy I was eating.
All the love, longing, frustration, and lust I felt for her I poured into licking and sucking Sarah’s pussy.
Although she continued to struggle it didn’t take too long to make her cum.
She wasn’t Mary-Beth so it wasn’t practically instantaneous, no, she made me work a little harder for it, but soon enough I’d tapped her spring and made it give up its bounty.
I lapped up her juice as she began pumping it out to the rhythm of her orgasm, but then I stood up, bending my knees and getting my cock into position.
She shrieked in fear as I once again rubbed her from her anus to her pubis and back, but this time down the center of her moist slit with the head of my cock.
Even though she was still cumming she managed to beg me, “No coach, please, I’m a virgin!” as I pressed the head of my cock into her tight hole.
“I know honey.” I replied in a breathy whisper. “And I’m gonna fix that for you.”
She yelped as the head of my cock was engulfed by her wet hole, and when I pulled out and quickly pushed back in she yelped again.
“N-no, p-please, st-sop.” Sarah stuttered as I began repeatedly violating her little hole, going in slower and deeper with every thrust until eventually I ran up all the way to the hilt so slowly it was almost painful.
No-no, no, no, no!” she begged desperately in a breathless whisper.
He mouth was saying no but her pussy was saying yes, opening to accept my cock, and providing all the lube needed for a smooth entry.
When I’d finally buried the full length of myself inside her I leaned in an began kissing her tears, grasping her wrists as Sylvia released them.
She actually put up fight when I grasped her wrists which surprised me but I easily overpowered her.
“Why are you doing this to me coach?!” Sarah sobbed desperately.
“Because you need it Sabine.” I hissed before throwing my hips into motion, fucking her at a nice leisurely pace as I held her wrists pinned over her head.
Although she tried to stay in character the motion was having an effect on her as she began involuntarily moaning to the rhythm of my cock penetrating her tight young pussy.
That’s when I started changing up the depth and speed of my stroke, pulling out all the stops.
Whenever I could I’d close my eyes and imagine Sabine, but most of the time I had Sarah locked into this really intense eye contact.
She tried to look away but was draw back to my stare so that we were looking straight at each other when I made her cum again.
Her eyes went wide with surprise when she felt another orgasm coming, and even though she was still playing the “victim” she couldn’t suppress a quick smile.
I seemed to be impressing her so far, but I had to make sure.
When I felt my orgasm approaching I pulled out and ate her pussy, keeping her stimulated while cooling myself down, and when I was ready I’d plunge back in and fuck her some more.
It was after her fourth orgasm that I couldn’t hold back anymore and asked, “Is it safe to cum inside you?”
She broke character so drastically that I stopped midstroke when she said, “Yeah, I’m on the pill.” but then she stopped and asked, “Are you gonna cum inside Sabine?”
Her eyebrows went up and she tilted her head slightly, pursuing her lips.
“Probably best not?” I asked rhetorically and she nodded her agreement.
I began pumping again, driving for my nut before panting, “Then I guess I’ll cum…”
“Dibs!” Jenny blurted out, cutting me off.
“Bitch!” Mary-Beth shot at her.
“You snooze you lose.” Jenny replied, shrugging her shoulders.
An argument over who gets to take my load between two fit young women is the last thing I expected I’d ever see, but I had been experiencing a lot of unbelievable things lately so I just added it to the list.
I let go of her wrists, wrapping my arms around her body as I began really pumping, fucking her hard.
She wrapped her arms around my neck and the girls let go of her legs which she also wrapped around me.
Clearly she’d dropped out of character and was gonna ride the rest of this out as Sarah, and Sarah equally clearly liked to fuck.
I closed my eyes for a moment, thinking of Sabine, and then I just started pounding that hot little pussy.
The volume went up dramatically with our bodies slapping together and Sarah suddenly wailing to the rhythm of my penetrating prick.
I glanced over at Mary-Beth who was still on her knees where she’d been holding Sarah’s leg, and couldn’t help noting her wild eyed expression of glee at seeing her friend getting railed.
“Oh yeah, fuck me coach!” Sarah managed to belt out.
I looked up at Sylvia and her crooked smile radiated what I can only describe as pride.
I could almost hear her thinking, ‘Yeah, that’s my man! Give it to her good Daddy!’
Next I checked on Jenny, since she was about to take this load.
She was still on her knees as well, but she was just staring in awe with her mouth hanging open.
Although I was too distracted fucking the hell out of Sarah at the time now I can’t help but appreciate how each responded to the spectacle according to her character.
I thought of my beautiful baby girl again, imagining I was fucking her, using that to drive it home when Sarah shrieked and started cumming again.
I could feel my orgasm approaching but she’d clamped her arms and legs around me, and pulling out in the middle of her orgasm just felt rude.
I began slowing my stroke, trying to hold in off, but her orgasmicly spasming pussy wasn’t helping.
When I felt her orgasm winding down I couldn’t hold back anymore so I announced in a strained voice, “I’m gonna cum!”
Sarah immediately released me so I stood and turned to Jenny who was ready for Freddy.
I couldn’t help notice Mary-Beth diving into my vacated position, finishing off Sarah with her tongue, and it was weirdly moving.
‘Now that’s what friends are for!’ I thought with a little tear in my eye as Jenny grasped my shaft, and wrapped her lips around the head.
She instantly began bobbing her head, sucking my cock and pumping the shaft with her hand.
The orgasm that I’d been approaching and pulling back from came roaring back with a vengeance as grasped Jenny’s head in my hands.
“Oh shit, oh shit, oh shit!” I began chanting breathlessly as my eyes rolled and I involuntarily rose up onto the balls of my feet.
This was going to be a big one and as the pressure built towards release I was almost scared of the power, but then it hit.
“Aaaaaaagggghhhhh!” I cried out in a quivering voice as everything went white and I was overwhelmed by the ecstasy of my first powerful blast of sperm.
“Mmmmmmm!” Jenny hummed excitedly as she stopped bobbing her head, but kept pumping the shaft, milking my cock into her mouth.
“Oooh God Jeeenny!” I moaned, looking down into her eyes as she drank my semen.
Suddenly I head a shriek and turned to see Sarah obviously getting off on Mary-Beth’s pussy eating skills.