I drew in a sharp breath at this revelation, astonished that he’d been planning for me to top him. “But you should work up to it at first,” I managed to say. “At least practice with a small plug and see how it feels to you.”
“Uh-uh,” he responded, shaking his head, and I watched his tongue slide over his lower lip. “I want you now.”
I closed my eyes, trying to calm my nerves. “But I’m afraid,” I confessed. “Everything else we’ve done, I’ve practiced for, but I can’t practice for this. I’m afraid I’ll hurt you, or that you’ll hate the way it feels…”
“Landon,” Foster said, his voice soothing, and I opened my eyes to look at him again. “We’ll take it slow, okay? If you find you don’t enjoy it at all, we can stop. And if I think it’s too uncomfortable, we won’t take it any further. But I’d like for us to at least try, if you’re open to the idea.”
Already I could feel my cock hardening, and I was honestly surprised at my arousal. Being naturally submissive with Foster, I would be in completely unfamiliar territory assuming this role. But Foster was right; I was curious about how it would feel to have my cock buried inside a tight ass. More specifically, his tight ass.
“Okay,” I finally said, giving him a smile. “We’ll try it.”
Foster smiled back at me, then brought his lips close to my ear. “Daddy wants your gorgeous cock, every single inch of it,” he told me in a husky voice. Of course that made my dick throb, and when he took my hand, I quickly stood and followed him to the bedroom.
We were out of our clothes in moments, and as Foster stood naked before me, I saw that he was definitely aroused. His erection seemed to be strengthening by the second. Closing the distance between us, I slid my palms over his chest as we shared another kiss. Then I told him, “I want to rim you.”
For the first time, Foster looked uncertain. “Are you sure?”
“Of course I’m sure!” I said.
Did he actually seem a little embarrassed? I asked myself. It wasn’t like him to be hesitant. “So I, um, tidied up my pubic hair for you, which I’m happy to do,” he said, “but I sure as hell didn’t feel confident enough to try to shave the hair around my ass this morning. If you want me smooth back there, you’re gonna have to help me out in that regard, Landon.”
Seeing him so nervous, almost shy, made me ache to reassure him. “Daddy,” I said, cupping his ass in my hands and giving his cheeks a squeeze. “Do you honestly think there’s anything about your body that doesn’t excite me? You think I’m going to mind a stray hair in my mouth while I’m eating your ass?” Those words made him draw in a sharp breath, and I could sense his longing, just as strong as mine was. “Now how about you get in that bed? I want you on your hands and knees for me.”
He was quick pulling back the covers of the bed I’d made earlier, and I watched with an eager smile as he got into the position I preferred. Then I moved to kneel on the bed behind him, caressing his back and his hips, his thighs and then his ass. His cheeks had some hair on them, but not nearly as much as what was on his legs. And as I spread him even wider, I found that the ring of flesh I so wanted to lick was circled by coarse hair, too. I’d felt it before, when I dared to explore his ass with my fingers, but now the sight of it made my cock twitch hard.
“Oh yeah, we’re definitely not shaving back here,” I said to him with a grin, then dipped my head so I could swirl my tongue over his puckered hole. Foster moaned in response, and I pressed my face firmly between his ass cheeks, delving in so I could fully explore, my tongue teasing, circling around before homing in and licking with unbridled enthusiasm.
“Ah, fuck yes!” Foster groaned. “That feels so damn good, baby!”
While my tongue gently probed, seeking entrance, I massaged his taint with my fingers, giving it plenty of attention. That seemed to make his muscles relax, and before long the tip of my tongue was granted access to his ass.
Foster actually began thrusting back against me, as if to take my tongue even deeper. By this point, my own cock was rock hard and leaking pre-cum. I’d never really fantasized about doing this, because I never believed Foster would let me, much less want me to, but now that I was eating his ass, I discovered I was wild for it.
I heard his heavy breathing mingled with lustful groans. As I continued pleasuring him with my lips and my tongue, I wrapped my fingers around his pulsing dick and stroked it.
“Christ, I’m too close now!” Foster panted, reluctantly withdrawing from me. “Don’t want to come yet.” He lay on his back, staring up at me with an unmistakable need. “My God, Landon, that mouth of yours is fucking incredible!”
I couldn’t hide my pleased smile. “Well, I’m happy to do that any time you want. I loved it.” Glancing down at my throbbing dick, I added, “As if that wasn’t obvious.”
Foster took my cock in his hand and began stroking it. “I’m ready to feel this inside me,” he said, his eyes locked with mine.
I swallowed hard, suddenly nervous all over again. But I understood how much he wanted us both to experience this, and I was determined to do all I could to make it enjoyable for him.
I retrieved the bottle of lube from the bedside table, and as I held it, I noticed I was trembling a bit. Still I mustered up what I hoped was a sexy smile for Foster’s benefit. His stare was hot as he watched me, and I saw his dick pulse, the beautiful tip flushed crimson now.
I was more than generous with the lube, using a ton of it on both of us. Foster sighed with pleasure when I slipped a lubed finger into his ass. “Feel good?” I asked him with a grin.
“Oh yes!” he replied. “Fuck, I’m so excited for this!”
I was excited, too, though still somewhat apprehensive. The last thing I ever wanted to do was cause him pain, and I told myself I would be so careful, watchful for any sign that he wanted me to stop.
With my erection looming out from me, I moved to kneel between Foster’s thighs. Taking a deep breath, I positioned the head of my cock at his hole. Then my eyes met his. “I’m gonna go really slow,” I assured him, and he nodded. I could sense how eager he was, and that made me feel more confident about taking him.
Gently, so gently, I started easing into his ass. “Oooh fuck!” I breathed. Glancing down between us, I saw that my cockhead was only halfway inside him, but already I was trembling from feeling how tight he was. How did anyone do this and not come within mere seconds? I wondered.
Looking back at Foster, I noticed his jaw was set in a firm line, as if he were bracing himself for pain. Sliding my palm along his thigh, I spoke in a soothing voice. “I know it’s easier said than done, but just try to focus on relaxing for me. And if it’s too much, we stop, okay?”
It was strange, being the one with so much control, but Foster’s eyes were trusting as he readily nodded, and I watched as he made a clear effort to relax. When he did, I worked a little more of my dick inside. Then I waited, letting him get used to it. All the while, his cock remained fully erect.