I placed the head of penis up against his asshole, both totally lubed from the soap. Slowly I pushed, watching as I penetrated him. It felt amazing, he was so tight. He looked back and squinted with some pain, so I took it slow. The whole tip of my penis was in. I waited, and he said “ok keep going”. I slowly pushed inch by inch into his muscular ass, and I knew I would cum without much more work. I slowly pulled back, able to tell he was enjoying it was much as I was. I reached around with my right hand and grabbed his dick again. As I did another slow thrust in, I pulled my hand in on his dick, masturbating him in rhythm with my thrusts. I increased speed on both fronts, until I knew I was ready to explode. I finished with a final quick few thrusts in his asshole, releasing the climax of my ecstasy. My dick in his butt was pulsating, resulting in tons of jizz. It was the most amazing ejaculation ive ever had, waves and waves of pleasure swept over me. I let out a very loud moan as I finished ejaculating. He turned back and smiled, but he still hadn’t come. So I slowly pulled my dick out, white cum leaking from his asshole behind it. He bent down and licked the cum off the tip of my dick. I then put my hands on the wall for support, and bent over with my ass cheeks spread out. I put soap all over my asshole with one of my hands, and then braced myself.
His purplish red tip pushed into my asshole, and I knew because he was pretty wide that it would hurt. Though for the first inch it was painful, after I let it settle I told him he could go ahead and use my asshole to give him his pleasure. He began thrusting all the way in and out, working up a fast pace. It felt incredible, icing on the cake for me. I could tell he was going to cum soon because of the speed he had going. He let out a much louder moan then I did, and I could feel his dick spasming, so I tightened up my asshole on it to make it even better for him. He slowed down, and then pulled out. His dick as still full on hard but it would soon be limp. I got down on my knees and let the shower rinse off the soap and fecal matter, and began to suck the last jizz out of his dick. I then stood up and we made out, sharing his bit cum in our mouths. He was an amazing kisser, probably from his practice on girls. We then washed eachother off in the shower while we were there, then toweled off afterwards. We got outside the gym, and we kissed and I grabbed his ass one last time before I went home for the night, and told him “Im ready to do that anytime to you want again”. He smiled and we walked our separate directions for the night.
After that night we began hanging out often and sucked eachother off after football practice when the other guys left, and had sex when we knew we could be in private. It was the greatest time of my life.