“Do you see it?” he asked.
“Not yet,” I said.
I lied, I had seen it just a moment before and wanted him to get the chance to see it, but I had a better idea. I put my leg in front of his and began boxing him out. There wasn’t much of a fight from him because he saw I was going to be bent over right in front of him. I can only assume he was hoping for some ass to cock touching. And I obliged gratefully. As I moved in front of him, I gave a nice big push with my butt, right up against his pelvis. I felt him thrust forward at the same time and I fell into the pool. I completely missed the toothpick. Irrelevant. I got back to the edge and stood back up. He watched me as I looked for the toothpick again. He was no where near it and as I looked at him, I noticed he had a raging hard on. He hadn’t moved and was just watching me to see if I would notice.
“You alright, Braxton?” I asked.
“I think I need to tell you something, if it isn’t apparent already.” He said soberly.
He stood there in all his chubby glory, cock hard. Well, it started going flaccid. I looked from it to him and saw he had trepidation in his eyes. A mild concern, but not too bad.
“Okay, go ahead”, I said with an attempt at seeming open and accepting.
“I’m gay”, was all he said.
“I know,” I said.
“So you’re okay with the fact that I just thrust my hips into your ass when you were boxing me out?”
“Yes I am. I put myself in a compromising position and you took advantage of me. Seemed fair play to me. Don’t you think?” I said, my cheeks feeling hot.
“Yes I do. If you’re willing to put your naked ass in front of a man you know is gay, then I think it’s fair you accept the consequences of your actions.” He said with an air of justice and finality.
“As do I.”
This flirty exchange was getting my blood boiling. My hands and feet were getting cold and my face was flush. Not to mention my phallus was betraying me. The direction this conversation was going, had my aroused. I was rock hard. He looked down and saw my erection. He walked up to me and showed me his erection had returned, too.
“Well, you said Lady Justice was weighing our fairness tonight, and I’m pretty sure I heard her say that since you touched my penis, I get to touch yours. Wouldn’t you agree?” He had a devious smile.
“I guess I can’t argue with fairness, I was the one who insisted we obey the scales, however they fall.”
“However, she doesn’t have any say on how I touch it.”
He dropped down to his knees and took my glands into is mouth and gently sucked. Then he ran his tongue around it while still holding me between his soft lips. I could tell he was freshly shaven. His chin and upper lip were smooth against my cock as he rubbed the side of it along his lips to the tip. He opened his mouth and took in 3 inches of my 6 inch cock(I’m rounding up). With his right hand, he grasped my left butt cheek. With his left, he grabbed my balls. He was gentle. He sucked me softly and firmly. Sometimes only licking and sometimes licking my balls. He moved his right hand between my legs and gently nudged my legs apart. Putting his palm on my taint, he slid his middle finger between my ass cheeks seeking out his target. He found it easily. With his middle finger he rubbed the outside of my anus, circling it and gently prodding with his finger tip. Having my hole played with like that was my favorite. I was fully engorged. As he prodded my rectum with his finger, he spread my ass open with his left hand and pushed my cock all the way into his mouth, balls deep. This was too much for me to handle. With a couple of pumps, he drained me.
“Braxton, I’m going to cum,” I said struggling to keep from exploding in his mouth.
Removing his mouth from my throbbing cock, he said “cum in my mouth, I want to taste you.”
“Oh my gosh, yes. I’m cumming.” I moaned.
His finger still rubbing my sphincter, ass spread half open, and cock deep in this beautiful, smooth chub’s mouth, I came harder than I had cum before. Greedily, he sucked as my cum shot into his mouth and down his throat. He kept sucking as I spurt my final blast and into my last pulse of aftershocks. Never, had I been so aroused. The build up was amazing. The teasing, the feeling of not knowing what would happen or if it would happen. The whole situation had created a perfect explosion. I was glowing.
Never being a selfish lover, I joined him on my knees and kissed him on his lips.
“That was amazing,” I said as our lips parted. “Now let me return the favor.”
I gestured for him to stand up, and he obliged. Standing up, he towered over me with his sexy, chubby belly right in my face and his torrid shaft pulsating near me lips. I saw the precum beading at the tip of his head and I licked it off. It didn’t taste fowl. It was sweet, with a slight tang. To me, nothing had tasted better. Wanting more I took his cock in my mouth and sucked him deeply. His girth was assuredly bigger than mine, and with my small mouth, he filled me up easily. His testicles were large, the size of avocado pits. I performed my best blow job. Licking the underside of his cock, lightly nibbling the sides and alternating between shallow and deep penetration. I found it difficult to take him all the way. I choked a couple times attempting and almost achieving balls deep. Eventually, I felt him start to throb in my mouth. I knew he was close. He didn’t give me any warning as he shot his load in my mouth and down my throat. I gagged and swallowed as he shot ropes of cum inside me. Following his lead, I kept working him until his last aftershock. I pulled away and looked up at him.
report “You didn’t give me a heads up,” I said, winking.
“I’m sorry, my mind was somewhere else.” A satiated smile on his face.
“I think you owe me an apology, but in the form of a good fucking.”
“I can definitely do that, but you’ll have to give me some time to recover.”
“Okay, do you still have energy to play toothpicks or do you want to rest?” I said hopefully. I very much enjoy games.
“I can play.” He said, smiling.
We played for a little while longer, occasionally touching each other. We weren’t shy anymore. He would slide his hand between my legs and grab my penis, gently. I would rub my ass against his cock to push him away and tease him at the same time. He would get hard every time and I eventually asked:
“You’re ready now? Here?!”
“Why not,” he replied flirtatiously, “but I think I’ll wait until later.”
Then I bent over on my hands and knees, arching my back so my butt cheeks spread as wide as they would go.
“You’re sure you want to wait?” I asked playfully, shaking my hips side to side.
“Well, I guess I could at least play a little.”
Practically pouncing on me, he knelt right behind me and buried his face in my ass. He prodded and licked my hole as if he wanted to tongue fuck me. I started relaxing my sphincter to give him more satisfying penetration. His tongue felt wet and warm, it pressed on my eager hole. I was head down, ass up, inviting him to take advantage of me. To use me as he saw fit. I wanted to feel him slide that beautiful cock deep inside me and breed my ass. I couldn’t wait to have him open me up, thrusting deeper as he buries his entire rod into me.