“Damn, you weren’t kidding about that 3 inches.” Jay joked, standing in his friend’s kitchen in his underwear himself. Ben was now in just his underwear.
“Shut up, dick. Crap, this door makes a lot of noise, how about you edit the dare.” Ben asked, hoping for mercy.
Jay thought about it for a minute. He was in his underwear too and the loud door was sure to wake his parents. They could come out to see what was going on. “Nah” Jay finally answered, holding Ben to the dare he came up with. Ben looked angry but opened the door and stepped outside quickly. Then Jay did something totally unexpected. The door was, in fact loud and he knew it probably had woke one or both of Ben’s parents. As Ben was running down the driveway, Jay shut the door and locked it. Then he quickly went back downstairs before with Thelma or Steve had a chance to come out and catch him. When Ben got back up and discovered the door locked he freaked out. He was also kinda upset, but was also still drunk so he thought it was kinda funny too. He began to walk to the sliding glass door to the basement. Just as he walked out of view his Mom looked out the window. She didn’t see anything and went back to bed.
Ben knocked lightly on the sliding glass door and Jay pulled back the curtain, laughing. He opened the door and let Ben in, but not before taunting him.
“That was bullshit. Totally not part of the dare.” Ben said, half mad half laughing.
“No one ever said you can’t pull a prank in the middle of truth or dare.” Jay replied. “Man, I think I need some more to drink.”
“OK, let’s run upstairs real quick and get some.” Ben said, thinking about both him and Jay being in their underwear and him with no shirt. “But we gotta make it quick in case my dad gets up.” The boys went upstairs into the kitchen. Ben poured 3 more shots each while Jay grabbed a pack of Smirnoff Ice drinks. These were his favorite type of drink to sustain an inebriated state. They chugged down all three shots each and made their way down the stairs with the other drinks. Then the game carried on. Ben made his last, non-8 ball but failed to make the 8 so he didn’t get the big dare. “Truth or dare” he asked Jay.
“Dare”
“I dare you to run upstairs and take 2 more shots.” Ben said. As Jay started toward the steps to go upstairs Ben spoke back up. “Naked.”
“Shit. I guess I have to.” Jay replied to the dare, the most risky one of the night. He was still pretty buzzed, but did know enough that if he got caught upstairs, naked, it would be an extremely awkward situation to explain. Ben had secretly wanted to see Jay’s cock ever since Jay accidentally touched his in the pool earlier. He had never had actual gay feelings, but this incident sparked his interest. He was excited that this situation had come up. Always having such a small dick, he was curious as to what his friends size was. Jay slid down his underwear and his large cock was revealed. Ben guess it was about 6 inches or so. It was very thick, however. Not something he could say about his own. Ben could see it start to harden and it grew a little bigger before Jay turned to head up the stairs. This make his tiny little dick start to grow. He walked up the stairs behind Jay and stayed at the top as Jay went through the door to get the shots.
As Jay was pouring his second shot he heard Ben’s parents room door open. It was Steve. He had gotten up to go to the bathroom but heard some noise coming from the kitchen so decided to go check it out. Jay was standing behind the island as Steve walked into the kitchen. It was just tall enough to not reveal he didn’t have pants on. By this time Jay’s dick was rock hard, all 9 inches of it.
“Good morning.” Jay joked, still buzzed but surely aware he could not let Steve see that he was nude inside his kitchen with a hard cock,
“Yeah, sure.” Steve chuckled. He began to walk over to the fridge. As he did this Jay moved his way around the other side of the island, making sure to keep his lower half of his body out of view. “Where’s your shirt?”
“Downstairs. It got kinda hot with the fire place.” Jay lied, using the electric fire place as an excuse to have no shirt in the middle of the night when Steve knew that he and Ben were still hanging together.
“Well tell Ben to turn it down.” Steve said as he grabbed something from the fridge and turned around to walk back to bed.
Jay was relieved as he downed the two shots he was dared to do. Throughout this entire situation, Ben was peaking through the basement door, stroking his tiny little cock. He couldn’t believe how much his friend being naked in his kitchen with his dad being right across the room from him was turning him on. As he saw Jay walking back toward the door, he put his cock away and moved back down the stairs.
“Damn that was close!” Jay said as he put his underwear back on.
“No shit. I wonder what he would have done if he’d seen that you were butt ass naked.”
“No idea, but I’d rather not find out.” It was now Jay’s turn and he went and sunk both normal balls he had left on the table, giving him two and leaving only the 8ball for both boys.
“Truth or dare?”
“I’ll take one of each, I guess.” Ben responded, dreading his turn after what happened to Jay upstairs.
“OK, first your truth. What happened in your dream that you wouldn’t tell me earlier?” Jay asked, really curious, especially since he had been secretly bi-curious for a while.
“Well…” Ben was trying to stall.
“Just spit it out man.”
“OK fine. We all took turns sucking each others dicks while the others fucked Sara. That’s all. Nothing more than oral.”
“Wow.” Jay responded. That was perfect because that’s all he ever had desire to do with a man. Sucking and getting sucked. The thought of anal sex with a man was not appealing to him at all.
“I dare you to drive up to McDonald’s and get me something to eat.” (I DO NOT ADVOCATE DRINKING AND DRIVING. IN FACT I STAND STERNLY AGAINST IT. THIS IS FICTION.)
“Man, that’s a weak dare. I was expecting a lot worse.” Ben said as he started putting his pants on to go get the food.
“Naked.” Jay said, doing the same thing to Ben as he had done earlier. “And that’s not all. Your cock must be hard as you pull up to the window to grab the food. I’ll ride in the back seat to make sure this happens.”
“Shit.” was all Ben could muster.
“And I’m not done. You have to ask the person handing you the food if they wanna ‘take care of this huge cock’ for you.” Jay said, barely controlling his laughter.
“Dude, this is going too far.”
“Fuck that, I’ve done all your shit. Now it’s your turn.”
“Goddamn it! I could kill you right now! Let’s go get this over with.”
The boys walk down to the car. Ben walking rather quickly hoping no one comes outside. By this point it is about 2:30am so it would be unlikely. Jay, still in his underwear walked more slowly. They got in and headed toward the McDonald’s. The boys pulled up to McDonald’s, Jay in the backseat and Ben driving. Jay leaned over to make sure Ben was hard before going through the drive through.
“Hey man, you gotta get that thing hard.”