I kept one of my hands on his dripping dick, but I leaned myself forward to take a closer look at his asshole.
I had not had dinner yet, and I was way too hungry to refuse the invitation.
The frenetic spams and throbs of Sam’s cock showed me that I did not have much more time before he would be done.
Unlike Sam, I was no expert freediver, but what the hell, I dove in, right in the manly ass-crack, tongue first!
The scent, the taste… WOW.
I heard both Kitty and Sam moaning and grunting above me, but as soon as I had tasted that ass, I was in my own world.
It was raunchy but I did not give a fuck.
It was exactly what I wanted… and more.
I had to let go of the glorious dick for a little while because I needed to spread those ass cheeks myself. I needed to go deeper. My tongue was made to feel every edge of that straight man’s anal cavity.
“Fuck yeah, Oliver! Keep going, that’s insane!” He groaned.
“MMMfff… Mmmfff…”
I wish I could have talked to tell him how yummy he was but see, my mouth and tongue were busy.
Kitty seemed to be moving around me but I stayed in the zone.
I could not let go of that pinkish tight asshole. I searched Samuel’s insides as if my whole life was depending on it.
All of the sudden, I felt a hand behind my neck, and then grabbing my hair. I was distraught at first.
Kitty had jumped from the couch and was now solely focused on making me eat her toy-boy’s ass.
“Eat him good, you’re gonna make him cum….” She pushed me.
Freed from the asshole he had been eating for nearly a half hour, Samuel was stroking himself while talking dirty.
The words were very similar to what I was used to hear through the bedroom’s wall at night, except that this time around, I was fully part of the action.
“Make me feel good… Fuck yeah… You’re gonna make me nut so bad… So freaking bad… You want my milk, eh?”
“MMMMffyes…”
“I’ll spray you with my cum, cunt…. Hmmm… Yes, use that tongue… So fucking nasty… Use it good… I’ve never done that before… That’s so bad… So filthy!”
Trust me, by this point, I was literally making love to his asshole with my mouth.
I swallowed some hair in the process but I could not give a fuck. I would have taken every inch of his body Samuel was letting me have.
Also, that was my very first experience with a girl! Can you believe it? Kitty fetched my cock and started jerking me off.
I learned only later on that she was really into gay sex herself, and one of her fantasies was to turn a gay guy straight. We were not so different after all!
I mean, since I was eating a very manly ass as she was jerking me off, I am not sure we can call this a success for her.
Although, I will grant Kitty that thanks to her efforts, she did turn me a little straight, while we turned Samuel much gayer.
“It’s coming… I… Come here… I want to spray your face… The both of you…”
Only the hope of swallowing some of Sam’s cum could have made me let go of his butthole.
Kitty did not let go of my cock, – I was about to bust my loads as well -, but she did free my hair from her hold, and instead, she glued her own face next to mine.
We were kneeling cheeks to cheeks, anxiously waiting an inch away from Samuel’s rod to get splashed!
And splashed, we were!
By now, I knew that Samuel was always nutting a lot but this time broke all the previous records, he aimed his first volley at Kitty who managed to get it straight in her throat, — she was definitely a pro -, and I was blessed with his second and third loads.
The first one hit me in my forehead and hair, but the second one went mostly in my mouth.
He had already given me a facial once, but this time, I really got to appreciate his sperm against my taste buds before swallowing it.
After that, Kitty and I had to fight to collect the following loads. It was difficult to focus because I was jizzing all over her hands at the exact same time.
Tasting Samuel’s fresh cum had made me lose control.
There had been no penetration involved. No blowjob either. There was a damn girl in the mix. Yet, this was the most intense sexual experience I had ever had.
By the end of it, the three of us were drenched with sweat and cum and we all went to the bathtub together. We needed a good clean-up.
Samuel did not seem to be shaken up by what had happened.
As always, he was very casual about the whole thing. Just another crazy sex experience for the insatiable trainer.
“That was hot, right?” He told as he started showering in between Kitty and I.
We were all standing in the tub.
“So hot.” Kitty confirmed.
I simply nodded yes.
I was at a loss for words.
Everything had gone so quickly and so unexpectedly that it was very much feeling like a fever-dream. Especially as Samuel started washing me with the lukewarm water, not being shy to use his hands all over my body…. And my ass in particular!
The prick, he was going to make me hard all over again!
Unfortunately, I was forced to witness that he was doing the exact same thing with Kitty on the other side a minute later.
She was giggling and kissing his chest playfully.
She even kissed his lips twice.
I remember vividly because that hurt me a little. I could eat Samuel’s ass but I did not have all the privilege and access to his entire body. I was not a hot girl…
Still, I enjoyed the moment and I could not be mad at Kitty.
report Especially as she came up with the most wonderful game right after our quick shower.
Yes, it turned out that the evening was far from over.
“Fuck, Oliver. Your ass is so smooth and peachy, really does look like a girl bum!” She commented as I was drying off.
“I know, right! I’m always thinking that!” Sam confirmed.
“Shut up, guys!”
I was offended when I should not have been, given what was coming next.
“Sam, I’m sure that if you didn’t know better, you could get our two asses mixed up!” Kitty said, checking her own ass in the mirror, comparing it with mine.
“Probably…” He stated mindlessly.
“Wait, guys… We should try!” She suggested.
“What?”
“I’ve just had the best idea! Oliver and I will get our two asses in line; we’ll blindfold Samuel and he’ll taste both! We’ll see if he can tell which one is which!”
I was completely stunned.
She could not be serious? Sam was not going to eat MY ass!
I guess that even after what we had just done, I was still very much naive because of course, Sam replied:
“That’s hilarious! What can we use as a blind-folder?”
[TO BE CONTINUED]