This was a lot to take in. My mind was racing and connecting the dots. Thinking of all the sleepovers the guys have had without me. The way too long showers they always took after football practice.
There was one tiny thing missing though: Joshua.
What the fuck did he have to do with this? How did he even know these guys?
Aaron saw me looking between him and Joshua who was glaring at him. ‘And two weeks ago,’ Aaron said casually, ‘Joshua joined in. And guess who he wanted to be his partner for life Dexy?’ Aaron said, before licking his own hand clean of Luke’s cum.
Joshua came up behind me, and as much as my brain was damaged in just about five minutes, and everything I thought I knew about my childhood friends was completely wrong, his warm arms around my waist didn’t make me feel just horny. But also the happiest guy alive as I turned around to kiss him. Still, it didn’t explain this crazy sexclub and how Joshua even knows the guys. ‘Okay but wait, how do you guys know Joshua?’ I asked the room at large. I was genuinely confused by this.
‘He’s in college with me.’ said Aaron, smirking at Joshua. I immediately got this jealous rush and flung my arm around Joshua’s waist, who was only looking at me.
‘As soon as he told me he knew you from school, and started rambling about you like a madman, I started to realise more and more that he had the hots for you. And I also immediately understood why you were acting so weird when you left the team.’ Aaron said proudly, as he stuffed Luke’s dick back in his trousers.
‘So I took my chance and told Joshua I was gay, and I thought he was too. I told him that you might like him back and that I would help him get to you. But only if he payed the price. And he agreed.’
I didn’t know what the heck he meant, but as soon as I saw the guilty, pleading look in Joshua’s eyes, I had a hunch.
‘You joined their crazy sexclub?’ I asked him softly, not wanting him to think I was angry. Because I wasn’t, in the end we did get together tonight. Which was my ultimate dream.
‘I’m sorry Dexter. I panicked! We both went to college and I thought I’d never see you again! And then I meet Aaron and he tells me he knows you and can keep us in touch. And on top of it all he tells me that the guy of my fucking dreams has a crush on me! I had to agree!’ He exclaimed. His eyes were pleading as he wrapped his arms around my neck and kissed me.
I could only get lost in the feeling of his warm lips, carresing mine slowly.
We hadn’t been at it for three seconds and I felt an hand jerk me away from Joshua
‘Ah, ah, ah,’ Brian said in my ear. ‘Didn’t you listen? We get to try you out before you can enjoy your lovey-dovey stuff.’
I’d hoped I didn’t catch that right, or I hoped that I could go jerk off right there.
Joshua came closer. ‘C’mon guys. I’ve been crushing on Dex since I first fucking saw him. You guys promised to help me get him if I slept with you. Just let it go, apparently Dex and I have both been waiting for two damn years! Just let us-‘
‘Nope! We get to decide.’ Jeremy cooed. Wohoho, what?
‘Wow wait! What? What do you mean?’
Aaron sighed. ‘You see Dexy, I always knew you were the same as us. The only difference was, you didn’t ever act on it. And we didn’t know why the hell you never made a move on any of us until just a few weeks ago when this guy,’ He pointed at Joshua, who was holding me from behind. ‘Until he just, completely coincidentally started talking to me in class. He’d seen Luke pick me up from class, and I started talking about liking guys and being gay. And he told me about his secret high school crush that he’d never dared to approach and regretted it hugely. And after he told me a bit about the guy, I realised he was talking about you! So I promised to tell him wether you were gay and had a crush on him in high school, in exchange for him participating in our little sexclub.’ Aaron winked at Joshua. Who blushed furiously and looked away from my eyes.
‘Of course, the second Joshie said he had a crush on you, all the pieces of the puzzle started to fall into place and I knew that you must’ve liked him too. So we helped Joshie there muster his balls and tell you he likes you, because neither of you were gonna do it otherwise. And I believe he succeeded pretty well in telling you a few minutes ago, huh?’ I couldn’t stop the wide grin from spreading on my face.
But the look that Aaron had plastered on his own face now unnerved me a little.
‘There was a catch though.’ He whispered huskily. ‘You’d have to participate as well, if it happened to work out for you guys. That’s why you’re here.’
I looked at Joshua, dumbfounded. ‘Wait a sec. So you traded me, for a chance to get me?’
Joshua sighed, ‘Uhm… yeah kinda. I’m sorry Dex, I had no idea what to do. I was afraid that I was gonna chicken out of telling you what I feel.’
‘But what do you feel? We kissed! I have no idea what the fuck is happening!’ I yelled.
Joshua looked desperate. ‘It’s just for once. You just have to do it one time and then we’re out and we can be together. Please Dex, I wanna be with you okay? I’ve had the biggest crush on you for ages! I even came out to my parents last night!’ He exclaimed.
That really surprised me, but in a good way. No one has ever done anything like that for me. To reveal that they’re into guys so that we don’t have to keep it a secret. All of a sudden all my high school feelings were rushing back tenfold. If this was true, if this could really be, then I’d do anything for it.
And before I knew it, I heard myself say: ‘Well, alright.’ I looked at Aaron ‘So how is this going to work? I suck your dicks in here and leave with my boyfriend?’ I felt Joshie smile against the back of my neck at the word boyfriend.
A devillish grin spread on Aarons face as the rest chuckled darkly.
‘You wish it were that easy, huh? I’m sorry Dex, but it’s a little more complicated than that. You’re going to be doing the same trial as Joshua did, which means you’re ours for two weeks, and no Joshua for that time.’
I wasn’t sure if I could even go two feet from Joshua now that I had him. But if it was the price to have him for myself. Then fuck it.
To be honest, I couldn’t be more turned on by the prospect of being “tried out” by the others.
So I made a decision.
‘Alright, I’ll do it. Two weeks, then you leave us alone.’ I said sternly, looking Aaron in the eye dead-serious.
‘Good, Dexy. Then you’ll receive further information tomorrow. Aaron winked and smirked at me. Luke looked at me with anger and jealousy, which scared me a bit since I had never seen him look at anyone like that before, let alone me.
I quickly turned around and kissed Joshua tenderly on the lips. The contact made us both groan in hunger. A second later he was pulled off of me by Brian and Jeremy.
‘Ours for two weeks, no Joshua.’ Whispered Leo, and he grabbed Joshua’s package out of nowhere. Joshua hissed in pain.
‘I’m gonna miss you, Joshie.’ He said as he licked Joshua’s neck and ear.
Joshua whimpered in pleasure, but kept his eyes locked on mine. As if to concentrate on the feeling Leo’s tongue, but imagining me in his place.